150- W STP-A: Comparison with UTP

Table of contents:

W STP A Comparison with UTP

It is presumed by many engineers that STP cabling, because of its shield, should be less susceptible to external noise and interference. This is not necessarily true.

In 1992 Robert Pritchard and Doug Smith compared the susceptibility of 150- W STP-A and UTP cables using the IEC 801-4 Electrical Fast Transient test method, a severe form of susceptibility testing [80] . These researchers concluded that "both UTP and STP can provide adequate immunity to interference." The susceptibility depends, in the case of UTP, on the symmetry and rate of twist of the wires. In the case of STP the susceptibility depends on the integrity of the shield.

Of these two dependencies, I would rather the integrity of my system depend on the twisting of the wires, because

Customers will not maintain the shields on an STP system .

The integrity of any STP system hinges on a continuous connection of the shield from end to end along the entire cable path . This requires good connections at multiple points along the way, with all the connectors firmly seated and no dirt or corrosion at any critical connection point. In my opinion such connections will not be properly maintained , and the shield will fail, leaving the system open to outside interference. STP may make sense for short interconnections, but not, in this author's opinion, for general-purpose building wiring.


  • Customers will not maintain the shields on an STP system.


Transmission Line Parameters

Performance Regions

Frequency-Domain Modeling

Pcb (printed-circuit board) Traces

Differential Signaling

Generic Building-Cabling Standards

100-Ohm Balanced Twisted-Pair Cabling

150-Ohm STP-A Cabling

Coaxial Cabling

Fiber-Optic Cabling

Clock Distribution

Time-Domain Simulation Tools and Methods

Points to Remember

Appendix A. Building a Signal Integrity Department

Appendix B. Calculation of Loss Slope

Appendix C. Two-Port Analysis

Appendix D. Accuracy of Pi Model

Appendix E. erf( )


High-Speed Signal Propagation[c] Advanced Black Magic
High-Speed Signal Propagation[c] Advanced Black Magic
ISBN: 013084408X
Year: 2005
Pages: 163

Flylib.com © 2008-2017.
If you may any questions please contact us: flylib@qtcs.net