Flylib.com

Books Software

 
 
 

You Stifle Yourself


You Stifle Yourself

Intimidation snuffs out creativity. Back when industrial manufacturing dominated the United States economy, companies were founded by a visionary genius and a few of his closest scientific or engineering peers. They had a lock on corporate creativity. Once the product went into the manufacturing phase, consistency and conformity were the most valued traits both in the product and in the workers who churned out hundreds and thousands of the product. The next Model T was supposed to be exactly like the previous one. The CEO did not want creativity—he (and it was a he ) wanted efficiency, output, and uniformity . Tyrants are very good at getting that.

What they are not good at is getting innovation out of their employees . Today, with an increasingly service-oriented and decentralized workforce, creativity is now important at almost all levels of most organizations. In a tyrannical atmosphere no one dares to suggest anything out of the ordinary. Consequently, there is no product improvement, no increase in efficiency, and no adaptation to the changing strategies of competitors . That is why the management tyrants are going the way of the dinosaurs.



Bumpy Ride

Finally, as Dave Ruf, CEO of Burns & McDonnell, notes, people abandon a tyrant at the first sign of trouble. Leona Helmsley was the queen of New York when her hotel empire was intact, but when she found herself in trouble with the IRS, people were coming out of the woodwork to get even with her. A former maid Helmsley had fired testified that she had said, "Only the little people pay taxes." It was an out-of-context quote that had no direct bearing on the specific legal issue that got Ms. Helmsley incarcerated, but the alleged statement got swirling international press— mainly because it showed the depth of hatred people felt toward her.

More recently, Martha Stewart was implicated in an insider trading scheme. While I have never met Ms. Stewart, books and public reports indicate that there are a lot of people who consider her to be very autocratic, and quite bluntly, many people do not like her. Unsurprisingly, at the very beginning of the scandal—before there was any solid support for allegations that she engaged in insider trading—reports surfaced that many of her friends had dropped her like a hot potato.

Historic figures from Mussolini to Nixon illustrate the same point. Tyrants only have friends while they are in complete control. At the first sign of a crack in the tyrant's organizational structure, everyone abandons him or her. Schadenfreude is a German word for the sinful pleasure people take in seeing high-level people fall from grace. People take a lot more pleasure in seeing tyrants lose their thrones than they do those who have gained their prominence through respect for others.



Rule 24: Spend More Time on Information Inflow Than Information Outflow

Overview

start sidebar
SNAPSHOT

Do you think it is more important to get information than to give direction?

Yes: 75 percent

No: 25 percent

end sidebar

We discussed earlier the negative effect management intimidation has on both organizational opportunity and employee creativity. Intimidation also has a seriously negative effect on information flow. If people are scared of you, they do not want to bring you bad news. Moreover, they will filter or distort the truth if they fear your reaction to it. So if you manage by intimidation , you either get bad information or no information. As Doug Bain of Boeing puts it, "If somebody is going to get screamed at, that somebody is less likely to bring you bad news that you need to know.... Most managers deal with information flow. And personality plays a big role in whether information is getting to them and flowing within the organization."

Several invincible executives I interviewed said that accurate information flow is perhaps the most essential factor in long- term success. According to Bill Marriott, "As soon as people stop talking to you, you are dead." Similarly, Juanita Hinshaw, CFO of Graybar Electric, says that developing faithful reporting channels is the key to professional advancement. You have to be reasonable in your expectations, however. Her rule is: do not surprise me three times. "I tell people what I need and want and let them do it. I will leave you alone to do your job as long as you keep me posted, keep me informed. Let me know if there are problems or other issues that I need to deal with.... I don't want surprises . And one of the rules I am really hard on is that you do not surprise me three times," according to Hinshaw. One surprise she can understand; twice is a problem, but she is a forgiving person; three times and you are out of here. Hinshaw simply will not work with someone who repeatedly fails to get her accurate information in a timely manner.

Admiral Prueher noted that the higher up you get in an organization, the more prone your subordinates are to shading the facts of a situation to make them more palatable to you. "When you get to be a flag officer [an Admiral]," according to Admiral Prueher, "you never get another bad meal and you never get the truth," he told me. Consequently, "you always have to look carefully at what people are telling you, second-guess their motives, and find people whom you can rely upon."

Therefore, while invincible executives do not micromanage , they do spend a lot of time gathering information. In fact, they spend more time getting information than giving direction. To gather information effectively, they utilize three strategies: (1) they cultivate the personal management qualities that facilitate the flow of information to them; (2) they put people around them who are conduits for accurate information; and (3) they put organizational structures in place that permit the free flow of information.