|
|
To include as many national portals as possible, we started with search engines, posted a request to the IS World list requesting help and added suitable entries from Microwho (an existing directory of portals and related sites). We first narrowed the list down by focusing on 26 countries, including those analyzed by Marcus and Gould (2000). Then, using WebZip (available at www.spidersoft.com), a complete copy of the initial page of each national portal belonging to those 26 countries was archived. Next, a program was written in Visual Basic to count the number of links from the HTML code for each national portal. For countries with more than one national portal, the one with the most links was selected. This provided the final set of 26 national portals that were studied in depth. While somewhat arbitrary, the national portal with the most links is arguably the most "full-service" and thus the best fit for the criterion used in this study.
Table 2 lists the common features present in most national portals, including Yahoo!, which is taken as the standard in our research. Almost all of the national portals have layouts similar to Yahoo! (i.e., Multicolumn Directory/Subdirectory with links, occasional frames and animated objects) except in few cases where the layout is unique (e.g., go-jamaica which appears to be aimed partly at tourists). When using Yahoo! as a standard, extra features are those that a national portal includes but Yahoo! does not, while missing features are those found in Yahoo! but not the national portal (see Table 3).
Directories | Display Items/Links | Other Features |
---|---|---|
Arts | Advertising | Customizable interface |
Community | Auction | |
Education | Games | Chat |
Health | Horoscope | Discussion Groups |
Media and | Job listings | Download options |
Newspaper | News stories | Free e-mail |
Music and Entertainment | Shopping | Free Home Page |
Sports News | Arts | |
Personals | Stock quotes | Community |
Politics | TV Listing | Education |
Religion | Weather | Health |
Science and Technology | ||
Tourism and travel | ||
Women Issues |
Portal Name URL No. of Links | Country/Language | Missing Items | Extra Interesting Features | Dominant Color/No. of colors |
---|---|---|---|---|
Ahijuna www.ahijuna.com.ar 171 | Argentina Spanish | Women's issues, religion, TV, Auction, Free Home Page, Stock Quotes, Discussion | Economy, humor, erotic (Diosas) | Gold 9 |
Matilda matilda.aaa.com.au 250 | Australia English | Email, free home page, women's issues, religion, personals, auction, stock quotes, horoscope | Economy, humor | Light yellow 4 |
Web Watch www.webwatch.be 90 | Belgium French | Health, women's issues, religion, politics, free email, free home page, TV, auction, games, sports, stock quotes | Personal pages - sex sites | Gold 4 |
Terra www.terra.com.br 179 | Brazil Portuguese | Arts, science, personals, music, religion, politics, free email, free home page, weather | Personal finance | Orange 6 |
Sympatico www1.sympatico.ca 197 | Canada English | Arts, science, education, media, religion | Kids & teens, business, personal finance | White 5 |
Sina www.sina.com.cn 293 | China. Chinese-Simplified | Media, religion, auction, free home page, horoscope | Business, military | Gold 4 |
Costa Rica www.info.co.cr 108 | Costa Rica Spanish | Community, women's issues, personals, religion, free email, free home page, TV, weather, auction, shopping, jobs, stock quotes, discussion, downloads, horoscope, news, games, chart | Business, culture, history | Light blue 5 |
Egypt Search www.egyptsearch.com 96 | Egypt English | Women's issues, personals, free email, TV, weather, auction, stock quotes, horoscope, downloads, games, chart | Egyptian culture | White 3 |
Canoe www.canoe.fr 173 | France French | Education, health, community, personals, religion, free e-mail, free home page, auction, jobs, discussion, chat downloads | Pull down menus | Very dark blue 9 |
Ins-Netz www.ins-netz.de 195 | Germany German | Arts, education, media, community, women's issues, personals, religion, politics, free email, free homepage, TV, auction, jobs, horoscope | Erotica, business, hobbies, real estate | Dark blue 6 |
Ghana Forum www.ghanaforum.com 34 | Ghana English | Science, media, community, women's issues, music, religion, free e-mail, free home page, TV, weather, auction, shopping, job, stock quotes, discussion groups, horoscope, news, games | Business Main page has very little - need to use subsidiary pages | Light brown 5 |
123India www.123india.com 219 | India English | TV, free home page, jobs, discussion groups, downloads | Emigration, dating, matrimonial, Bollywood | Light yellow 5 |
Catcha www.catcha.co.id 156 | Indonesia English | Community, free home page, TV, auction, shopping, stock quotes, sports | Children's stories, business | White 5 |
Kataweb www.kataweb.it 279 | Italy Italian | Science, women's issues, personals, religion, politics, auction, free home | Business | White 5 |
Isize www.isize.com 239 | Japan Japanese | Arts, science, media, health, women's issues, personals, music, religion, politics, free email, free home page, TV, auction, discussion, games, chat | Personal finance, real estate, marriage planning | White 12 |
Malaysia Directory www.malaysiadirectory.com.my 184 | Malaysia English | Customizability, Horoscope Download options, Top news stories, Women issues, religion, | Martial arts as sport, Koi Fish forum as hobby | Yellow 9 |
El Sitio www.elsitio.com/elsitio/mexico 100 | Mexico Spanish | Science, Politics | Entertainment including erotic entertainment is explicitly profiled | Blue Yellow 14 |
Menara www.casanet.net.ma 134 | Morocco French | Religion, Games, Health in general, Politics, Education, Stock quotes are absent but financial news are covered, Auction | Soccer as sport is highly profiled, although an Islamic country, Islamic reference is non-existent implying a more secular trend in Moroccan society, woman's issues are well presented | Grey 7 |
Zoek www.zoek.nl 191 | Netherlands Dutch | Auction, Free Web page, | Sex related matters and links are prominently profiled. Soccer as sport is noted. | Deep blue 11 |
Pinoy Central www.pinoycentral.com 121 | Philippines English | Horoscope | Extensive links for immigration, Shopping site for remittance by the Philippinos working abroad | Blue 13 |
Onet www.onet.pl 210 | Poland Polish | Indirect links to erotic sites and adult contents. Polish beauty pageants related displays are prominently displayed | Yellow 11 | |
Aport www.aport.ru 291 | Russia Russian | Stock quotes, Free Web page, Auction | Science coverage is substantial, erotic entertainments are explicitly linked, family is focused widely, Soccer and ice-hockey as sports are profiled | Blue 10 |
Genie www.arrakis.com 209 | Spain Spanish | Politics, Jobs | Spanish cooking is well profiled, Soccer-mania is mentioned | Green 9 |
Spray www.spray.se 162 | Sweden Swedish | Auction, Science, | Green 9 | |
Mirago www.mirago.co.uk 113 | UK English | Stock Quotes, Chat, Customizability, Free Web page, E-mail, Religion, Science, Auction | Yellow 10 |
Since national portals tend to be designed by and targeted towards individuals belonging to the same cultural group, we may reasonably believe intrinsic cultural traits have been incorporated in the visual design of the interface. Among the various visual effects offered by national portals, we focused on color and layout. Colors reflect strong cultural values, much deeper than mere appearance. For example, green is generally considered an Islamic color, saffron yellow as Hindu/Buddhist, and red-blue-white-gold are colors of the Judeo-Christian West (Marcus and Gould, 2000). They identify color as an important new issue for global web user interface design, and suggest that the use of color could be related to Hofstede's Uncertainty Avoidance Dimension. Color could provide redundant cues (to reduce ambiguity for high uncertainty avoidance cultures) or maximize information without redundancy (for low uncertainty avoidance cultures). Colors were visually inspected to determine which was dominant by counting patches of color and the number of distinct color blocks. This provides some indication of the colorfulness of the portals.
The layouts of all the national portals are found to be very similar to that of Yahoo! (multiple columns in rectangular arrangements), with only the layout of Go-Jamaica being different (semicircular arrangement of items each being a circular object). Thus, no further analysis of layout was performed.
|
|