What s the Problem?

What's the Problem?

Before discussing ways to prevent or cure problems with adaptive AI, we must first identify them. Picking out problems involves a combination of external observation and analysis of the internal workings of the system.

No Learning

Symptom: Learning does not occur, or happens inconsistently.

Example: The decision tree for weapon selection usually selects the weakest weapon, despite better alternatives being available.

Diagnostic: The model or the implementation is (partly) broken.

Remedy:

• Debug the code and design.

• Verify the source code, comparing it to the theory.

• Validate the model by step-through analysis.

Uncontrollable

Symptom: The learning does not match specific results, or degenerates over time.

Example: The reinforcement learning animat does not retreat when it has low health, but instead attempts heroic attacks.

Diagnostic: The system is not equipped to reliably provide the desired control.

Remedy:

• Use explicit ways to control the learning with supervision.

• Design an architecture to deal with the control problem without learning.

• Limit learning to other subsets of behaviors or actions.

• Decrease the learning over time as performance reaches satisfactory levels.

Suboptimal

Symptom: Learning does not reach the perfect result.

Example: The average error of a neural network used for target selection is high.

Diagnostic: The design does not assist the adaptation; the system relies on optimality.

Remedy:

• Design the system such that suboptimality is not a problem.

• Provide hints to the learning by example (supervision) or guidance (feedback).

• Model the problem better so it's easier to find the best solution (for instance, expert features).

Unrealistic

Symptom: The behaviors are not realistic enough during the adaptation or at the end of the learning.

Example: Learning to aim causes the animat to spin around in circles for a few seconds.

Diagnostic: There is too much to learn; the policy is not designed for realism; the actions are inappropriate.

Remedy:

• Learn as much as possible offline.

• Select a better policy that rewards safe exploration and exploitation.

• Design the actions at a higher level to reduce the unrealistic combinations.