Synchronization Accuracy

When you're implementing synchronization, the question of accuracy arises: What is the acceptable offset between streams that are supposed to be synchronized? There is no simple answer, unfortunately , because human perception of synchronization depends on what is being synchronized and on the task being performed. For example, the requirements for lip synchronization between audio and video are relatively lax and vary with the video quality and frame rate, whereas the requirements for synchronization of multiple related audio streams are strict.

If the goal is to synchronize a single audio track to a single video track, then synchronization accurate to a few tens of milliseconds is typically sufficient. Experiments with video conferencing suggest that synchronization errors on the order of 80 milliseconds to 100 milliseconds are below the limit of human perception (see Kouvelas et al. 1996, ⁸⁴ for example), although this clearly depends on the task being performed and on the picture quality and frame rate. Higher-quality pictures, and video with higher frame rates, make lack of synchronization more noticeable because it is easier to see lip motion. Similarly, if frame rates are low ”less than approximately five frames per second ”there is little need for lip synchronization because lip motion cannot be perceived as speech, although other visual cues may expose the lack of synchronization.

If the application is synchronizing several audio tracks ”for example, the channels in a surround-sound presentation ”requirements for synchronization are much stricter. In this scenario, playout must be accurate to a single sample; the slightest synchronization error will be noticeable because of the phase difference between the signals, which disrupts the apparent position of the source.

The information provided by RTP is sufficient for sample-accurate synchronization, if desired, provided that the sender has correctly calculated the mapping between media time and reference time contained in RTCP sender report packets, and provided that the receiver has an appropriate synchronization algorithm. Whether this is achievable in practice is a quality-of-implementation issue.