Tool 39: Consensus Decision Making


AKA

Consensus Generator

Classification

Decision Making (DM)

Tool description

The consensus decision making tool is an interactive process in which all team participants openly communicate their ideas and reserve feedback and other points of view. The process continues until all team participants are able to accept and support a team decision even though some may not completely agree with it. Reaching consensus often requires greater individual participation, clear communication, and some compromise on well-considered decisions.

Typical application

  • To reach agreement on a proposed action or next step in a problem-solving effort.

  • To gain general agreement and support on a particular idea or issue.

  • To allow team participants the opportunity to express and defend their point of view.

  • To avoid conflict or rush to a decision.

Problem-solving phase

Select and define problem or opportunity

Identify and analyze causes or potential change

Develop and plan possible solutions or change

Implement and evaluate solution or change

Measure and report solution or change results

Recognize and reward team efforts

Typically used by

Research/statistics

3

Creativity/innovation

Engineering

2

Project management

Manufacturing

Marketing/sales

Administration/documentation

4

Servicing/support

Customer/quality metrics

1

Change management

start sidebar
links to other tools

before

  • Brainstorming

  • Brainwriting Pool

  • Futures Wheel

  • Affinity Diagram

  • Window Analysis

after

  • Team Process Assessment

  • Resource Requirements Matrix

  • Objectives Matrix (OMAX)

  • Responsibility Matrix

  • Action Plan

end sidebar

Notes and key points

  • Consensus is reached when:

    • All participants have presented their views.

    • Participants fully understand, accept, and will support the team decision.

    • Even if some participants are not fully satisfied or cannot completely agree with the decision, they do feel that they "can live with it" and will not oppose it.

Step-by-step procedure

  • STEP 1 The team displays a final list of ideas, a proposed problem solution, or process improvement activity. See example Increase Customer Contact Time for Complaint Handling.

  • STEP 2 Team participants clarify all issues, share views, and listen to other ideas or concerns. Ensure that all actively participate in this discussion.

  • STEP 3 After all information has been shared and alternatives considered, the team develops general agreement with care being taken to avoid conflict, participants taking sides, or outright blocking of compromise.

  • STEP 4 Lastly, the team creates a final decision statement and verifies that all participants understand and are willing to support their decision.

Example of tool application

click to expand




Six Sigma Tool Navigator(c) The Master Guide for Teams
Six Sigma Tool Navigator: The Master Guide for Teams
ISBN: 1563272954
EAN: 2147483647
Year: 2005
Pages: 326

flylib.com © 2008-2017.
If you may any questions please contact us: flylib@qtcs.net