Results

Online time is a measure of how long a subject spent online, using the MLSS system, in working on the task. This was measured in minutes using the MLSS system's built-in log file system, and was the total time spent online working on the task.

As clearly shown in the above table (see Table 1), there were significant differences between subjects of differing skill levels and interaction modes. Both of these were highly significant at p < .01. Command language interaction by novices clearly took the longest time (216.37), followed by command language by experienced users (137.78). However, there was little difference between the results across skill levels, for users of the wizard (67.09 for novice and 67.45 for experienced).

Table 1: GLM Analysis of Performance/Online Time: Means by Condition (Minutes)

Symbol

Condition

Novice

Experienced

All Conditions

CMD

COMMAND

216.37

137.78

177.55

WIZ

WIZARD

67.09

67.45

67.27

 

All Subjects

141.70

103.12

122.41

GLM Results

 

Significance

Model

F =99.90

p = .000

[a]

SKILL

F = 18.97

p = .000

[a]

MODE

F = 154.96

p = .000

[a]

SKILL [b] MODE

F=19.33

p = .000

[a]

** = Significant at p< .05

[a]Significant at p< .01

[b]Significant at p < .1

System satisfaction is a measure of how satisfied subjects were with the system they used, which in this case was the MLSS software. System satisfaction was measured using a composite system satisfaction scale. The questionnaires and scales used in this research were generally consistent with those used in past NJIT research, which include both research projects and dissertation research (Benbunan, 1997; Dufner, 1995; Fjermestad, 1995; Ocker, 1995).

The results, shown in Table 2, indicate there were significant differences between subjects of differing interaction modes (p < .01), but there were no significant differences between skill levels (p > .1). There was a significant difference when the interaction of skill level and interaction mode was considered (p < .01). In general, wizard users showed a higher level of system satisfaction, and while novice users preferred the wizard, experienced users preferred the command language. It appears, however there is a greater difference for the novice users, as compared with the experienced users.

Table 2: GLM Analysis of System Satisfaction: Means by Condition

Symbol

Condition

Novice

Experienced

All Conditions

CMD

COMMAND

24.24

18.85

21.55

WIZ

WIZARD

15.34

19.67

17.51

     
 

All Subjects

19.72

19.26

19.53

GLM Results

 

Significance

Model

F = 238.20

p = .000

[a]

SKILL

F = .497

p = .481

 

MODE

F = 29.01

p= .000

[a]

SKILL [b] MODE

F= 41.88

p= .000

[a]

** = Significant at p< .05

Note: Smaller values indicate higher system satisfaction

[a]Significant at p< .01

[b]Significant at p < .1



Computing Information Technology. The Human Side
Computing Information Technology: The Human Side
ISBN: 1931777527
EAN: 2147483647
Year: 2003
Pages: 186

flylib.com © 2008-2017.
If you may any questions please contact us: flylib@qtcs.net